Sno. | From | Status | To | EDS Date | EDS sought/Replied | EDS Letter |
1
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
02/03/2020
|
Please submit hard copy
|
|
2
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
05/08/2020
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
3
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
23/09/2020
|
reply to the observations as per attached letter may be furnished to this office.
|
|
4
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
23/09/2020
|
EDS
|
|
5
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
23/09/2020
|
Please attend EDS
|
|
6
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
28/09/2020
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
7
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
28/09/2020
|
Please submit reply in hard copy
|
|
8
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
03/10/2020
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
9
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
07/10/2020
|
EDS has been attended please
|
|
10
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
16/10/2020
|
EDS has been attended
|
|
11
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
17/10/2020
|
EDS has already been attended
|
|
12
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
19/10/2020
|
EDS has been attended
|
|
13
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
29/10/2020
|
The CA scheme placed and uploaded on the portal is not in order. Although in the details of CA, the forest area 7.50 ha has been mentioned but in the scheduled of plantation programme, the cost of CA and maintenance has been calculated over 3.6693 ha,
|
|
14
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
29/10/2020
|
The CA scheme placed and uploaded on the portal is not in order. Although in the details of CA, the forest area 7.50 ha has been mentioned but in the scheduled of plantation programme, the cost of CA and maintenance has been calculated over 3.6693 ha,
|
|
15
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
30/10/2020
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
16
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
30/10/2020
|
EDS has been attended to by DFO J/Nagar.
|
|
17
|
Regional Office
|
EDS
|
State secretary
|
12/03/2021
|
The state govt. may attend the following shortcomings as per the attachment here
|
|
18
|
State secretary
|
EDS
|
Nodal Officer
|
16/03/2021
|
EDS
|
|
19
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
16/03/2021
|
EDS
|
|
20
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
18/03/2021
|
Please attend the EDSs raised by higher ups
|
|
21
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
18/03/2021
|
Please attend the EDS
|
|
22
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
26/06/2021
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
23
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
28/06/2021
|
Please submit the reply in hard copy
|
|
24
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
07/07/2021
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
25
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
09/07/2021
|
Please attend the observation
|
|
26
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
15/07/2021
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
27
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
15/07/2021
|
Please submit the reply of observation No. 7 as per this officer letter No. 1825 dated 09-07-2021.
|
|
28
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
24/07/2021
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
29
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
29/07/2021
|
EDS has been attended please
|
|
30
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
05/08/2021
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
31
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
31/08/2021
|
Kindly attend the observation as per copy of EDS is attached
|
|
32
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
03/09/2021
|
EDS
|
|
33
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
03/09/2021
|
Please attend EDS
|
|
34
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
17/09/2021
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
35
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
18/09/2021
|
Please submit the reply in hard copy alongwith required documents.
|
|
36
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
27/09/2021
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
37
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
04/10/2021
|
EDS has been attended please
|
|
38
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
12/10/2021
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
39
|
Nodal Officer
|
REPLY
|
State secretary
|
11/11/2021
|
Complete reply is submitted.
|
|
40
|
State secretary
|
REPLY
|
Regional Office
|
12/11/2021
|
Complete reply is submitted.
|
|
41
|
RO/HQ
|
EDS
|
( ROSHIM )
|
12/01/2023
|
EDS raised and file returned back to IRO Shimla
|
|
42
|
Regional Office
|
EDS
|
State secretary
|
13/01/2023
|
EDS
|
|
43
|
State secretary
|
EDS
|
Nodal Officer
|
27/01/2023
|
eds
|
|
44
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
27/01/2023
|
eds
|
|
45
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
28/01/2023
|
EDS
|
|
46
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
28/01/2023
|
Please attend EDS
|
|
47
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
30/01/2023
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
48
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
01/02/2023
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
49
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
07/02/2023
|
EDS has been attended and uploaded online.
|
|
50
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
13/03/2023
|
EDS
|
|
51
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
14/03/2023
|
EDS
|
|
52
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
16/03/2023
|
Please attend EDS
|
|
53
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
22/03/2023
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
54
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
22/03/2023
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
55
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
25/03/2023
|
Submitted for further n/action please.
|
|
56
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
27/03/2023
|
EDS
|
|
57
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
28/03/2023
|
EDS
|
|
58
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
01/04/2023
|
Please attend the EDS
|
|
59
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
07/04/2023
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
60
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
12/04/2023
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
61
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
30/05/2023
|
EDS has been attended online web portal please.
|
|
62
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
05/06/2023
|
eds
|
|
63
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
05/06/2023
|
EDS
|
|
64
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
10/06/2023
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
65
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
14/06/2023
|
kindly attend the observation as per eds dated 05/06/2023 & submit the complete reply
|
|
66
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
14/06/2023
|
EDS has been attended.
|
|
67
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
16/06/2023
|
As per per telephonic discussion, proposal is forwarded for further necessary ation
|
|
68
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
16/06/2023
|
as per telephonic massage the case has been returned back.
|
|
69
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
20/06/2023
|
As per telephonic discussion, the case has been forwarded for further necessary action please.
|
|
70
|
Nodal Officer
|
REPLY
|
State secretary
|
06/07/2023
|
Complete reply is submitted
|
|
71
|
State secretary
|
REPLY
|
Regional Office
|
06/07/2023
|
Complete reply is submitted
|
|
72
|
Regional Office
|
EDS
|
State secretary
|
19/01/2024
|
The State Government may attend the shortcomings attached herewith.
|
|
73
|
State secretary
|
EDS
|
Nodal Officer
|
19/01/2024
|
EDS
|
|
74
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
19/01/2024
|
EDS
|
|
75
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
20/01/2024
|
EDS
|
|
76
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
24/01/2024
|
Please attend the EDS and submit compliance
|
|
77
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
27/03/2024
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
78
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
16/04/2024
|
he reply to EDS is not in order. Please go through point wise EDS and supply reply accordingly from your level.
|
|
79
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
03/07/2024
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
80
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
23/07/2024
|
Please find enclosed point wise reply to EDS dated 19.01.2024. Same has been uploaded at Sr. No. 8 in additional information also.
|
|
81
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
05/08/2024
|
EDS has been attended please.
|
|
82
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
13/08/2024
|
The Density in NPV bill has been mentioned as Open Forest and Very Dense forest which is not correct , as density of complete proposal patch should be calculated as a whole for trees involved in proposal. Additionally, the class of trees mentioned in online part-II , NPV bill, enumeration list are not similar , Please recheck.
|
|
83
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
13/08/2024
|
The Density in NPV bill has been mentioned as Open Forest and Very Dense forest which is not correct , as density of complete proposal patch should be calculated as a whole for trees involved in proposal. Additionally, the class of trees mentioned in online part-II , NPV bill, enumeration list are not similar , Please recheck.
|
|
84
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
20/08/2024
|
NPV rate applied correctly keeping in view the density of Forests. Since it is hydel project and there is long distance from one site to another. Thus keeping in view site specific area of Forest it is not logical to apply density as a whole in order ot safegaurd the interest of Forest and Govt. Further list of Trees checked and found correct.
|
|
85
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
20/08/2024
|
DFO J/Nagar has submitted that NPV rate applied correctly keeping in view the density of Forests. Since it is hydel project and there is long distance from one site to another. Thus keeping in view site specific area of Forest it is not logical to apply density as a whole in order ot safeguard the interest of Forest and Govt. Further list of Trees checked and found correct. Submitted for further n/action please.
|
|
86
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
30/08/2024
|
Please recheck the detail of trees in online Part-II and detail mentioned in NPV bill and send the reply accordingly.
|
|
87
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
31/08/2024
|
Please recheck the detail of trees in online Part-II and detail mentioned in NPV bill and send the reply accordingly.
|
|
88
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
13/09/2024
|
The details of trees checked and corrected in accordance with the record. Also, bill of NPV re-checked and found correct keeping in view the density of Forests/areas which are situated very far from each other and can not be merged as a whole for calculation of density as one area keeping in view the interest of Forest/Govt. welfare
|
|
89
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
18/09/2024
|
The details of trees checked and corrected in accordance with the record. Also, bill of NPV re-checked and found correct keeping in view the density of Forests/areas which are situated very far from each other and can not be merged as a whole for calculation of density as one area keeping in view the interest of Forest/Govt. welfare
|
|
90
|
Nodal Officer
|
REPLY
|
State secretary
|
20/11/2024
|
Complete reply is submitted
|
|
91
|
State secretary
|
REPLY
|
Regional Office
|
20/11/2024
|
Complete reply is submitted
|
|
92
|
Regional Office
|
EDS
|
State secretary
|
27/02/2025
|
State Govt may attend the shortcomings attached herewith.
|
|
93
|
State secretary
|
EDS
|
Nodal Officer
|
27/02/2025
|
eds
|
|
94
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
27/02/2025
|
EDS
|
|
95
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
28/02/2025
|
eds
|
|
96
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
06/03/2025
|
Attend and comply the EDS pertain to you
|
|
97
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
20/03/2025
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
98
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
10/04/2025
|
reply to the EDS dated 25.02.2025 along with requisite documents submitted point wise from point 9 to 11 in additional information.
|
|
99
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
24/04/2025
|
eds has been attended, submitted please.
|
|
100
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
26/05/2025
|
The observation 1 is regarding the project in question. please confirm by submitting requisite documents that how many projects are existing in the Nallah River Tributary in vicinity of Thaltu khod HEP 5.00 MW for the process of assessing the carrying capacity.
|
|
101
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
27/05/2025
|
The observation 1 is regarding the project in question. please confirm by submitting requisite documents that how many projects are existing in the Nallah River Tributary in vicinity of Thaltu khod HEP 5.00 MW for the process of assessing the carrying capacity.
|
|
102
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
31/05/2025
|
The observation 1 is regarding the project in question. please confirm by submitting requisite documents that how many projects are existing in the Nallah River Tributary in vicinity of Thaltu khod HEP 5.00 MW for the process of assessing the carrying capacity.
|
|
103
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
01/07/2025
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
104
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
18/07/2025
|
NOC from both selling and buying parties is to be uploaded with the reply.
|
|
105
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
08/08/2025
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
106
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
08/08/2025
|
In pursuance to Nodal Office EDS dated 27.05.2025. The details of existing project in the Nallah River Tributary in vicinity of Thaltu Khod HEP 5.00 MW Stage-II obtained from competent authority and there are four projects and details of the same enclosed herewith with their carrying capacity. Same has been enclosed at Serial No. 9 in additional information also.
|
|
107
|
CF (Mandi)
|
REPLY
|
Nodal Officer
|
14/08/2025
|
In pursuance to Nodal Office EDS dated 27.05.2025. DFO J/Nagar has submitted the details of existing project in the Nallah River Tributary in vicinity of Thaltu Khod HEP 5.00 MW Stage-II obtained from competent authority and there are four projects and details of the same enclosed herewith with their carrying capacity. Same has been enclosed at Serial No. 9 in additional information also.
|
|
108
|
Nodal Officer
|
EDS
|
CF (Mandi)
|
02/09/2025
|
Considering Thaltu I, II, III there seems to be a clear intention of obviating the provisions of CAT plan. If all four projects are in the same catchment, why should there not be a CAT plan.
|
|
109
|
CF (Mandi)
|
EDS
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
03/09/2025
|
Considering Thaltu I, II, III there seems to be a clear intention of obviating the provisions of CAT plan. If all four projects are in the same catchment, why should there not be a CAT plan.
|
|
110
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
EDS
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
04/09/2025
|
Considering Thaltu I, II, III there seems to be a clear intention of obviating the provisions of CAT plan. If all four projects are in the same catchment, why should there not be a CAT plan.
|
|
111
|
User Agency (cliffhydro207@gmail.com)
|
REPLY
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
24/09/2025
|
The correction have been made as per the instruction received
|
|
112
|
DFO (J/Nagar)
|
REPLY
|
CF (Mandi)
|
08/10/2025
|
Reply of EDS dated 03.09.2025
|
|